I promised that I would, on occasion, write to the theme of Things That Used To Be Simple But Are Now Unnecessarily Complicated, and so here I go. I am a little afraid that I am going to come off as a curmudgeon, because there are people who seem to enjoy the things that I see as Unnecessarily Complicated. But what's interesting is that we used to get along very nicely before these complicating things came into existence, and we were all a little less stressed.
Case in point: Kids' birthday parties. When I was a kid, birthday parties were a rarity. I had a party with friends for my 5th and 13th birthdays, and that's it. I was invited to a handful of birthday parties for other kids over the years. It's possible that I would have been invited to more if I'd been more outgoing, but I think it was just typical for that time and place. My two best friends from elementary school through high school never had a non-family birthday party that I know of. We had another friend whose parents both worked, a real novelty in those days, and she had a slumber party every year until high school. But that was the exception.
The parties were simple affairs. A daytime party meant birthday cake and punch, and some easy games like Pin the Tail on the Donkey. And of course the birthday cakes were all made by moms, not Safeway. Gifts were small and limited to whatever we could afford with our allowances -- an all-day sucker, paper dolls, drugstore cologne. There were no treat bags. A sleepover meant pizza, ice cream, and dancing to 45s. There weren't any video players and there was nothing for kids on TV. We just hung out in somebody's rec room and amused ourselves. (I probably shouldn't have mentioned the 45s. You're going to think we were listening to Elvis and Ricky Nelson. I'm not that old! Remember, the Beatles' singles came out on 45s.)
We noted birthdays in school, but very simply: the class would sing, the teacher might make you a crown out of construction paper and glitter, and that was it.
Why did this change? I tend to blame a lot of the costly complexity in our lives on the excesses of the Reagan years. People began to aspire to a higher social position. Or, rather, merchandisers realized that they could convince people that they needed to aspire to a higher social position. I don't think the party companies came into businesses because people demanded their services; it was the other way around. They created a need. At the same time, people were having fewer children, and they tended to lavish more attention on each one. At any rate, once the birthday juggernaut got started, it was impossible to stop.
I can't even tell you how many birthday parties my children are invited to every year. There is some event at least once a month. Almost all of the children I know have had a birthday party with friends every single year of their lives.
I have to confess that I bent to peer pressure. My girls have also had birthday parties every year, starting with their 4th birthday. I have tried to keep them reasonable. For several years, we did parties outside our house because we didn't have enough space to host them: we did Build-a-Bear, the craft store, McDonald's, the skating rink, that sort of thing. I keep the guest list down to seven or eight kids (this is difficult because my children have sophisticated social lives, and they have overlapping clusters of friends from school, daycare, activities, and even their China travel group). I don't think we've ever spent more than $150 on a party; I'm sure my parents' generation would be appalled, but it doesn't sound too bad to me.
Now that we have a rec room and the girls are older, we're more apt to have slumber parties at our house. I think the formal birthday parties tend to taper off as the kids get into high school. There isn't a strong tradition of having Sweet Sixteen parties in our area, thank goodness.
For the most part, the parties the girls have attended for friends have been on the same scale as theirs. I do remember a 5th birthday party that Bess attended at a girl's home. There must have been 30 kids there. They had hired a clown and brought in a bouncy castle. There were hot dogs and hamburgers and cake and soda. These were people of limited means, but they went all out for their little girl. Bess doesn't remember this party; I wonder if the birthday girl does?
Of course, we've all heard horror stories about parents spending thousands of dollars on kids' parties, or moms having panic attacks because they are afraid some little detail might not be perfect. And I'm starting to hear about people receiving children's birthday invitations that include a link to a gift registry. Ack.
I haven't seen any really extravagant parties yet, but even the modest annual parties we have around here are not completely benign. There is a tendency for expectations to escalate -- if one girl has a Build-a-Bear party for seven, the next girl will have a Libby Lu party for 10. (Those Libby Lu parties are not cheap.) The really fancy parties, with entertainers and limousines, may be just around the corner.
And these parties are often just one of several events at which the child will be the guest of honor -- there may be a party for friends, another for relatives, and another at home on the child's actual birthday, plus most parents will also bring cupcakes to school on the child's birthday. I've even seen them bring pizza and treat bags to school -- more escalation and competition.
(I have to confess that sometimes the school party comes in handy. One year Ella did not have a birthday party because she wanted to invite her entire class of 30 kids and I could not get her to pare the list down. So we just brought cupcakes to school and called it good.)
The result is that kids begin to feel that they are entitled to a big fuss. They are feted in a manner previously reserved for the Queen of England. They don't have birthdays anymore, they have birthweeks. It tends to create an inflated sense of their own place in the world.
And it adds to the river of stuff that runs through our lives. Kids attending parties don't give the token gifts we used to give, they give really nice gifts that their parents have bought on their behalf. Nobody wants to seem cheap or ungrateful. It's no longer enough to give a basic Barbie -- you have to give a Barbie playset, with clothes and accessories. Heaven forbid that you give a book. It's not glitzy enough. (I always love it when people do give books, and I'll bet a lot of parents feel the same way even if the kids don't.)
Some years, the gift-giving has been overwhelming. My kids have a large extended family -- five grandparents, 14 aunts and uncles, nine cousins. Add gifts from friends to the gifts they receive from relatives and it's just too much. For the past few years I have given the kids the option of not receiving gifts from friends. One year Ella had a book exchange at her party instead -- each child brought a wrapped book, and each child took home a book chosen at random. For the past two years Bess has asked friends to bring donations of pet food for the animal shelter. I know some children ask for donations to Half the Sky and other charities. I don't want to force it on them; I think this needs to come from their hearts. So far they have responded.
I have mixed feelings about requesting no gifts; part of being friends with someone is learning what they like and choosing something you think they will enjoy. But the kids tend to solve this by taping a candy bar or lip gloss to a birthday card along with the bag of dog food. In effect, they have gone back to the level of gift-giving we observed when I was young. So far the gift-free parties have worked very well.
Which brings me to my personal bugaboo, the treat bag. How did this become de rigeur? Is it not enough for the guest to have a chance to make something or be entertained, to eat some cake and Cheetos and play with friends? Why must they be provided with a cellophane bag containing small plastic toys and candy? Not to sound ungrateful, but we have enough small plastic things at our house, thank you. And a kid who has just had cake and ice cream doesn't need a Tootsie Pop. But kids are so accustomed to receiving treat bags that they stand in line by the door at the end of the party, looking around for the box containing their expected goodies (which will be dumped on the floor of their bedrooms and forgotten within 30 minutes). I have been to one or two parties where there were no treat bags, and at first the kids seemed disappointed. Ten minutes later, they had forgotten about it, and they were enjoying memories of skating or swimming together.
I don't necessarily begrudge my kids their parties. Annual parties are part of the culture now. I'm glad they have a lot of friends and that they are well liked. I want them to share good times with their friends. I would like to see the expectations scaled down, however. I'd like to see a return to the cake, ice cream, and Pin the Tail on the Donkey parties. I think you'd see a lot fewer meltdowns among the preschool set. I'd like to return to the custom of limiting school parties to a paper crown. I'd like for parents who feel pinched for lack of time or money to be able to excuse themselves from the birthday treadmill without their children becoming pariahs. Birthdays Without Pressure has some great suggestions for simplifying birthdays.
And I'd sure like to see those treat bags become a thing of the past. I think the Goodwill is tired of me seeing me come in with a big box of plastic novelty items twice a year.
Recent Comments